Why we choose to disbud our goats on our farm🐐

Disbudding is a controversial topic in the world of goat farming, and we understand why. The idea of removing the horn buds of baby goats may seem harsh at first glance. But at Blackwattle Dairy, we’ve carefully considered the whole picture and believe it’s essential that we disbud our goats—not just for our safety but for the safety and well-being of our goats. Here’s why we’ve made this choice and how we approach it with the utmost care.

Why disbudding is essential

In a farm setting, horns can pose significant risks. Goats are naturally curious and social animals, which means they’re always poking their heads into things or playfully sparring with each other. For goats with horns, this curiosity can quickly lead to danger:

  • Getting stuck: Horns can become trapped in fences and feeders. On a hot day, a goat stuck in the sun for hours can face life-threatening dehydration or heatstroke.
  • Injury risk: In close quarters, horned goats can unintentionally harm one another. A playful headbutt or territorial scuffle can escalate into serious wounds. Particularly around the eyes or face.
goats-with-head-stuck

Our goats already get their heads stuck enough without the hassle of horns. Goats seem to make it their goal to do the impossible. I would have never though they could have fit three heads through the one hole. But they proved me wrong. By disbudding, we’re not just protecting our goats from these risks. We’re also creating a safer, less stressful environment for them to thrive.

The human factor

It’s not just the goats who benefit from disbudding. Working with horned goats comes with real dangers for humans, even when the animals mean no harm. I’ll never forget the time one of my horned goats threw her head at a neighbour during a typical goat quarrel over grain. Her horn narrowly missed my eye as I bent to pick something up off the ground. That close call was enough to convince me that disbudding was necessary. Not just for the goats’ safety but for mine as well.

How we disbud

We approach disbudding with care and compassion, ensuring the process is as stress-free as possible. While some advocate for using anaesthesia, experienced goat keepers know that anaesthesia can be more risky for goats than other livestock, with some goats never waking up. Instead, we administer a pain-relief anti-inflammatory medication about 10 minutes before the procedure. This approach minimizes discomfort and allows the kids to bounce back quickly—often literally! 

I’ve watched kids get up moments after the procedure, hopping and playing as if nothing happened. I even have the video to prove it, I felt I was more traumatised by the experience. Still, we’re always looking to improve. We’re working with our vet to explore the possibility of using light sedation in the future, balancing the risks and benefits to ensure the best outcome for our goats.

IMG_1213

I have absolutely no idea how he got his head into such a small gap. Lucky I found very quickly and got him out with no harm done.

Looking ahead: The polled goat project

In an ideal world, goats wouldn’t grow horns at all, and disbudding wouldn’t be necessary. That’s why we’re keeping a close eye on breeding programs aimed at developing naturally polled (hornless) goats. While the science is promising, it’s not without challenges. 

The gene for polled goats is linked closely to a gene for hermaphroditism (to read more click here), which can complicate breeding efforts. To avoid these risks, polled goats can’t be bred together, which limits how many polled kids are born in each generation.

Despite these hurdles, there is positive results coming about through scientific research (to read more click here). We’re hopeful that polled genetics will one day be a viable option for our herd, and we’re eager to participate in these breeding programs as they advance.

Putting the goats first

At the end of the day, every decision we make comes down to what’s best for our goats. Disbudding isn’t a choice we take lightly, but it’s one we believe is necessary to ensure their safety and well-being—and ours. One bad day for a lifetime of ease. 

By taking these steps, we create a harmonious, happy environment where our goats can thrive, and we can focus on what we love most. Crafting delicious, artisan cheeses for you to enjoy. 

Have questions about our disbudding practices? We’re always happy to chat. To know more about our ethical practices click here. Reach out or follow us on social media for more behind-the-scenes insights into life at Blackwattle Dairy.

Follow Us on Social Media

Shopping Cart